Preponderance of Probability.
Preponderance
of Probability Latest News
The judgment on the title battle over the 1,500 square yards in the town of Ayodhya is founded on the “test of preponderance of probabilities” over who had possession of the outer and inner courtyards of the disputed premises, according to former Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud.
About
Preponderance of Probability
It
is a widely accepted standard of proof in civil proceedings.
The
preponderance of probability refers to the greater likelihood of one event or
fact over another.
In
this context, a fact is considered proven when the evidence suggests that the
occurrence of the fact is more likely than not.
It
is not about certainty or eliminating all doubts but rather about weighing
evidence to see which side presents a more probable scenario.
In
civil cases, the party bearing the burden of proof needs to show that their
version of events is more plausible than the opposing party’s.
This
standard contrasts sharply with the criminal law standard of “beyond a
reasonable doubt,” where the prosecution must prove the defendant’s guilt to a
much higher level of certainty.
In
civil cases, by contrast, the balance of probabilities leans toward the more
convincing narrative.
In
Narayan Ganesh Dastane v. Sucheta Narayan Dastane (1975), the Supreme Court of
India stated that under Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, a fact is said to
be proved when the court believes in its existence based on a “preponderance of
probability.”
The
court applies this test by evaluating conflicting probabilities and choosing
the most probable scenario.
Application
of Preponderance of Probability in Civil Law
The
preponderance of probability is the standard of proof used in most civil
litigation.
Civil
cases typically involve disputes over rights, contracts, property, or torts,
and the plaintiff must demonstrate that their claim is more likely true than
false.
For
example, in a breach of contract case, the plaintiff must show that it is more
likely than not that the contract was breached
📌 Visit Us:
🌐
Website: statisticsaward.com/
🏆
Nomination: statisticsaward.com/award-nomination/
📝
Registration: statisticsaward.com/award-registration/
Comments
Post a Comment